A lot of media sites which used to allow readers to post their thoughts in response to articles have since shut down their comments sections; and that has had me thinking about whether the Comments section at The Gate should remain open or be closed.
Close or Keep Open the Comments Section at The Gate?
One of the more notable Internet web sites which had recently closed its notorious comments section is Yahoo!, which has both the following message and a button on which to click to start a survey after every article:
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting. In the meantime, we welcome your feedback to help us enhance the experience.
“We’re thick-skinned enough to be able to deal with someone who disagrees with our opinions”, Joe Kurheg wrote in this article for Your Mileage May Vary. “However, we’re not going to turn our site over to people who want nothing more than to spew hate out into the world.” He then includes five guidelines for commenting on an article at Your Mileage May Vary:
- Don’t make insulting, demeaning or any type of racist, sexist or any other discriminatory comment in your post. That’s a 100% guarantee your comment won’t get approved.
- You must stay on topic and add something constructive to the conversation. Merely calling us or another commenter stupid is not adding anything and no one else besides us needs to waste time reading your words.
- If you notice a mistake, kindly forgive us – we’re only human. Please do let us know but be aware that although we may fix the error, we may or may not publish your comment because it doesn’t really add to the topic (see #2).
- Be kind and respectful. We understand that people might have different opinions and that’s usually a good thing. Being able to discuss these topics like adults can broaden the horizons of all our readers. But if you’re not polite about it, your post won’t be approved.
- In this time of the #coronacrapola, everyone is on edge. This might just be the time to realize that if someone doesn’t agree with you about traveling, maybe it’s a good idea to keep your feelings to yourself.
Summary
Despite my personally being outright attacked over the years by certain commenters — I hesitate to call them readers because that would imply that they actually read the article on which they were commenting — I vehemently support keeping the Comments section open for every article which is posted by me at The Gate. I want to continue to have a place where you can freely speak your mind without retribution, as I believe that the right to freedom of speech has been increasingly contracted lately; and I do not censor nor impose any rules for commenting — although purely “spam” comments are either deleted or never approved.
I intend to keep the Comments section open for as long as The Gate remains in existence, which is 14 years this month and counting — but I still would like to know your thoughts; so please post them in the Comments section below…
Photograph ©2019 by Brian Cohen.